#1 | 23.2%
| The Phantom from the Phantom of the Opera | |
#2 | 19.6%
| Andrew Jackson from Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson | |
#3 | 13.1%
| Princeton from Avenue Q | |
#4 | 10.1%
| Prince Eric from the Little Mermaid | |
#5 | 6.5%
| Cornelius Hackl from Hello, Dolly! | |
#6 | 6.0%
| Link Larkin from Hairspray | |
#7 | 5.4%
| Melchior from Spring Awakening | |
#8 | 3.6%
| Bobby Child from Crazy for You! | |
#9 | 3.6%
| El Gallo from The Fantasticks | |
#10 | 2.4%
| Nicky Arnstein from Funny Girl | |
#11 | 2.4%
| The Cat in the Hat from Seussical | |
#12 | 1.8%
| Marius Pontmercy from Les Misérables | |
#13 | 1.2%
| Roger from RENT | |
#14 | 0.6%
| Sky Masterson from Guys and Dolls | |
#15 | 0.6%
| Tony from West Side Story | |
#16 | 0.0%
| Danny Zuko from Grease | |
#17 | 0.0%
| Raoul de Chagny from the Phantom of the Opera | |
#18 | 0.0%
| Sonny from Xanadu | |
#19 | 0.0%
| The Beast from Beauty and the Beast | |