The top 19 Pitcher selector results of 48 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Pitcher selector.

#1	52.1%	Curt Schilling
#2	14.6%	John Smoltz
#3	4.2%	Barry Zito
#4	4.2%	Derek Lowe
#5	4.2%	Greg Maddux
#6	4.2%	Tom Glavin
#7	2.1%	Eddie Guardado
#8	2.1%	Eric Gagne
#9	2.1%	Kazuhiro Sasaki
#10	2.1%	Mariano Rivera
#11	2.1%	Matt Morris
#12	2.1%	Pedro Martinez
#13	2.1%	Randy Johnson
#14	2.1%	Trevor Hoffman
#15	0.0%	Armando Benitez
#16	0.0%	Jarrod Washburn
#17	0.0%	Jon Jieber
#18	0.0%	Roger Clemens
#19	0.0%	Troy Percival