The top 10 Baseball Stars Selectors results of 122 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Baseball Stars Selectors.

#1	53.3%	Cal Ripken
#2	23.0%	Albert Belle
#3	13.1%	Luis Gonzalez
#4	4.1%	Juan Gonzalez
#5	2.5%	Roger Clemens
#6	1.6%	Barry Bonds
#7	0.8%	Frank Thomas
#8	0.8%	Jeff Bagwell
#9	0.8%	Sammy Sosa
#10	0.0%	Mike Piazza