News & comments posted organically
SelectSmart.com
Report spam & abuse

SelectSmart.com home page

The problem with Amy Coney Barrett's judicial philosophy of Originalism

By Curt Anderson
October 12, 2020 10:56 pm
Category: Law
(2.5 from 2 votes)
SelectSmart.com    SelectSmart.com    SelectSmart.com

Share
The posted rules of the Post
Rate this article
(5=best, 0=poor)
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Star
0 Stars

(Excerpted from Originalism, Amy Coney Barrett's approach to the Constitution, explained By Ian Millhiser, Vox.com. See link below)

Originalism, in [Judge Amy Coney] Barrett's words, is the belief that “constitutional text means what it did at the time it was ratified and that this original public meaning is authoritative.”

In reality, however, following the text of the Constitution is more complicated than it sounds.

For one thing, the Constitution is riddled with ambiguous language. What are the "privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States"? What makes a search or seizure "unreasonable"? If the government wants to deny "liberty," how much "process" is "due"? What's a "public use" of private property? What is the "general welfare of the United States"?

Then there's the problem of precedent...

To give one rather stark example, there was a robust debate among early Americans about whether it is constitutional for the federal government to fund "internal improvements" such as roads and canals. As president, James Madison even vetoed an 1817 bill funding such construction because he deemed it unconstitutional.

Madison's views are now widely rejected. But suppose that a Supreme Court dominated by originalists concludes that Madison was correct. Does that mean the entire federal highway system must be torn up?




Another problem with Originalism, is that the Founders were not clairvoyant. They could not envision the entire future from their 18th century perspective.

For example, the First Amendment mentions "the press" meaning newspapers and other printed matter. Radio, television and the Internet were beyond their imagination. We assume, but cannot know from their written words, that they intended to protect all of modern news media from government interference.

Likewise, in the Second Amendment, the "individual right to keep and bear arms" in an age of muskets didn't foresee the weaponry technology of the today.

When the Bill of Rights was written, only only white male adult property owners who were at least 21 years old could vote. Depending on the state, a man needed to own fifty or hundred acres of land to have the right to vote. Women and non-white people had no voting rights. Since only voters could serve on juries, most people could not truly have a jury of their peers.

That was our original voting rights and restrictions. Not many people today would advocate that we return to that era.

Cited and related links:

  1. vox.com
The views and claims expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and beliefs of SelectSmart.com. Not every statement made here can be assumed to be a fact.
Comments:

Be the first to comment on this article.




Cookies Consent Policy & Privacy Statement. All Rights Reserved. SelectSmart® is a registered trademark. | Contact SelectSmart.com | Advertise on SelectSmart.com | This site is for sale!


From our contributors:
Display Order:
Biden takes a page from FDR's book; Trump took a page from Hitler's book.
by Curt Anderson     February 26, 2021 12:32 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [3565 views]


Four Years Ago In Trump History
by Curt Anderson     February 25, 2021 7:22 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [941 views]


Attack On Titan Season 4 Finale Title Surfaces Online
by Curt Anderson     February 24, 2021 2:48 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [2998 views]


How much of an advantage is home court in the NBA?
by Curt Anderson     February 17, 2021 9:22 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [7706 views]


In praise of gtnish7
by Curt Anderson     February 13, 2021 12:27 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by gtnish7 (1 comments) [4177 views]


The precarious balance in the US Senate should remind Democrats to make hay while the sun shines.
by Curt Anderson     January 27, 2021 5:39 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [19155 views]


Arguments why Trump shouldn't be impeached and tried a second time.
by Curt Anderson     January 22, 2021 7:14 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by Donna (1 comments) [5816 views]


Here's how we can avoid electing Donald Trumps in the future
by Curt Anderson     January 8, 2021 2:26 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [15637 views]


Discover The Meaning of Your Life
by numo777     January 6, 2021 6:52 am (Rating: 0.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [3971 views]


A good explanation as to how COVID vaccines work.
by Curt Anderson     December 24, 2020 6:47 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [11855 views]


Whatever happened to Biden accuser Tara Reade?
by Curt Anderson     December 13, 2020 1:42 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [12945 views]


How Numerology Can Decode Your Future (2021)
by numerology2021     December 12, 2020 10:36 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [1387 views]


Would Bernie Sanders have defeated Trump?
by Curt Anderson     November 24, 2020 12:34 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [21674 views]


For comedic reasons I am glad the election was close.
by Curt Anderson     November 9, 2020 7:35 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [14690 views]


Yoga Teacher Training course in noida
by sohum     October 27, 2020 4:45 am (Rating: 0.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [12492 views]


Did the Democrats dodge a bullet by nominating Joe Biden instead of Bernie Sanders?
by Curt Anderson     October 20, 2020 9:42 pm (Rating: 0.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [7835 views]


The problem with Amy Coney Barrett's judicial philosophy of Originalism
by Curt Anderson     October 12, 2020 10:56 pm (Rating: 2.5)
Last comment by (0 comments) [10389 views]


Newman! Seinfeld's nemesis urges you to vote early.
by Curt Anderson     October 9, 2020 2:50 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [3420 views]


Trump's Nobel Peace Prize nomination means less than you think.
by Curt Anderson     September 9, 2020 1:29 pm (Rating: 3.5)
Last comment by Curt Anderson (1 comments) [6973 views]


Don't let revisionists tell you that the Civil War wasn't about slavery.
by Curt Anderson     October 6, 2020 9:13 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [3421 views]


Trump's Supreme Court nomination may have just hurt his chances with the voters he needs.
by Curt Anderson     September 27, 2020 10:40 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [11183 views]


RBG's death has sparked an eyepopping flurry of contributions to Democrats.
by Curt Anderson     September 19, 2020 3:04 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [8087 views]


What was Bob Woodward's responsibility in reporting on what Trump said about COVID?
by Curt Anderson     September 14, 2020 7:32 pm (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [4950 views]


Who actually accomplished progressive change in America? A case for Joe Biden.
by Curt Anderson     September 6, 2020 11:25 am (Rating: 5.0)
Last comment by (0 comments) [3483 views]


Find old posts & articles

Recently rated items