The top 18 Survivor: All-Stars results of 282 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Survivor: All-Stars.

#1	34.4%	Amber
#2	18.4%	Kathy
#3	9.9%	Alicia
#4	6.7%	Lex
#5	6.0%	Jenna L
#6	5.7%	Rob C
#7	5.7%	Rob M
#8	3.5%	Rudy
#9	2.5%	Shii Ann
#10	2.5%	Tom
#11	1.8%	Colby
#12	1.1%	Jenna M
#13	1.1%	Rupert
#14	0.4%	Jerri
#15	0.4%	Tina
#16	0.0%	Ethan
#17	0.0%	Richard
#18	0.0%	Susan