The top 10 Which American Idol Star Are You? results of 1283 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Which American Idol Star Are You?.

#1	24.6%	Tamyra Gray of American Idol
#2	16.8%	A.J. Gil of American Idol
#3	15.1%	Nikki Mckibbin of American Idol
#4	13.6%	Kelly Clarkson, American Idol winner
#5	8.0%	EJay Day of American Idol
#6	7.4%	Jim Verraros of American Idol
#7	5.9%	Ryan Starr of American Idol
#8	4.6%	Justin Guarini of American Idol
#9	2.2%	Christina Christian of American Idol
#10	1.8%	R.J. Helton of American Idol