The top 5 Which American Idol Girl Are You results of 37 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Which American Idol Girl Are You.

#1	67.6%	Britney Spears
#2	16.2%	Kelly Clarkson
#3	10.8%	Mandy Moore
#4	5.4%	Jessica Simpson
#5	0.0%	Christina Aguilera