#1 | 21.9%
| When you are evil, you will be like Dawn in season six | |
#2 | 13.2%
| When you are evil, you will be like Buffy in 'When She Was Bad' | |
#3 | 12.0%
| When you are evil, you will be like Xander in 'The Pack' | |
#4 | 11.5%
| When you are evil, you will be like Willow in season six | |
#5 | 11.1%
| When you are evil, you will be like Giles as Ripper | |
#6 | 9.5%
| When you are evil, you will be like Riley in season five > | |
#7 | 6.7%
| When you are evil, you will be like Buffy in 'Living Conditions' | |
#8 | 4.8%
| When you are evil, you will be like Jenny in 'The Dark Age' | |
#9 | 3.1%
| When you are evil, you will be like Willow as a vampire | |
#10 | 2.9%
| When you are evil, you will be like Angel as Angelus | |
#11 | 2.0%
| When you are evil, you will be like Xander as a vampire | |
#12 | 1.3%
| When you are evil, you will be like Faith after 'Bad Girls' | |