Vehicles Poll: Car Insurance Comparison Tool Vote for your top choice from the list below. This poll is based upon the selector "Car Insurance Comparison Tool" by Impartial Judge. Translate: Choose from this list: Amica Mutual Auto Insurance Erie Insurance Auto-Owners Insurance Shelter Auto Insurance State Farm Auto Insurance GEICO Auto Insurance Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance American Family Auto Insurance MetLife Auto Insurance Alfa Auto Insurance Sentry Auto Insurance USAA Auto Insurance Progressive Auto Insurance Kemper Auto Insurance GMAC Auto Insurance The Hartford Auto Insurance Grange Auto Insurance Allstate Auto Insurance Travelers Auto Insurance The General Auto Insurance Safeco Auto Insurance Esurance Auto Insurance Nationwide Auto Insurance AAA known as the Automobile Club Group, ACG Auto Insurance Farmers Auto Insurance See the newest and search for polls here: