Kinda the Robin Hood argument
I guess you would also have to consider not only is it against freedom who manages the redistribution?
How much trust do you have in your wealth manager?
I understand all taxation = redistribution most of us believe in taxes but why do we desire to economically punish the successful? Is that a good message to promote? We want to help the homeless, children, the elderly, the sick... But should we redistribute wealth by mandate to make a poor persons life a tad more comfortable?
Try to see both the pros and cons if you can